52 Ancestors in 52 Weeks: (Week 2) Origins - Mistake(s) in Tree(s)

Attention fellow genealogy enthusiasts! There's been a mix-up in my family tree line that needs addressing. It's about Hannah JONES Stuart from Neshoba County, Mississippi and a certain Hannah Mariah DELBRIDGE.

Here's the deal: No marriage record has been found for Hannah Jones and William Davis Stuart in Alabama or Mississippi, but she is NOT the same person as Hannah Mariah Delbridge who married another William Stuart in Clark County, Missouri on 10 Mar 1850. This confusion has been floating around for at least three years, and it's high time we set the record straight.

The root of the mix-up? Well, it seems someone mistakenly linked these two Hannahs years ago, and the error has been replicating in our trees like wildfire. But let's not rely solely on others' trees. Our research should be deeper, digging into actual records to distinguish one Hannah from another.

On 3 May 1857, Mrs. Hannah M. Stewart marries Lewis Logan in Clark County, Missouri.

Missouri, U.S., Marriage Records, 1805-2002, Mrs. Hannah M. Stewart, Ancestry.com

There are family trees at Ancestry that list the above Hannah's maiden name as HOUGHAM born 21 Jul 1817 in Highland County, Ohio, and died 16 Aug 1876 in Heyworth, McLean County, Illinois. Note: I have not proven this information so it should be researched further. There is a marriage record for Hannah Houghman to Joseph Delbridge on 1 Jan 1835 in McLean County, Illinois. Source: Illinois, U.S., Marriage Index, 1860-1920, Ancestry.com.

Let's now focus on Neshoba County, Mississippi records for the other Hannah Stuart who married William Davis Stuart/Stewart. Below is a clip from the 1860 U.S. Federal Census for Neshoba County. W.D. Stewart and Hannah are listed on it with their children.

1860 U.S. Federal Census, Neshoba County, Mississippi, Township 12, Range 11, W.D. Stewart, Ancestry.com

One Hannah is in Clark County, Missouri. The other Hannah is in Neshoba County, Mississippi. There are other records that also support the lives of these "Hannah's" in different locations. These two women have been merged into one woman in many trees at Ancestry.

A confession – I'm not immune to errors myself, even after almost 30 years of genealogy research. But hey, we strive for accuracy, right? So, let's join forces, double-check those records, and ensure our family history is as precise as possible. Happy hunting!

This content was crafted for Amy Johnson Crow's 52 Ancestors in 52 Weeks challenge, focusing on the theme "Origins" this week.

- Revis

Surname Sunday: Festevan and All Its Variations

Exploring the Surname: FESTEVAN

The surname FESTEVAN has intrigued me for quite some time, primarily because of its diverse spellings. It's fascinating how one surname can have so many variations! Delving into my family tree, I discovered that my ancestor, John W. Festevan, belongs to my paternal grandmother's lineage.

John W. Festevan claimed Holland as his birthplace. While tracing his journey, I (and other family genealogists) found records of him residing in Mississippi and eventually passing away in Louisiana. The puzzle deepens when we explore his place of birth. A significant number of genealogical trees on Ancestry pinpoint his birthplace as "Holland, Reusel-de Mierden, Noord-Brabant, Netherlands". However, I have reservations about this information.

Upon further research, I came across an insightful post by renowned Dutch Genealogist, Yvette Hoitink, CG®, QG™. She sheds light on the often-cited location "Reusel, Reusel-de Mierden, Noord-Brabant, Netherlands" that frequently appears in many family trees. Drawing from her expertise, I've gained a new perspective, leading me to question the widely accepted birthplace of John. The link to her article is here at Dutch Genealogy.

A glimpse of John's life

Below is a chart that gives us a look at John’s life, and some of the spellings used in documents or records relating to his life and transactions.

Category	Information
Name	John W. Festevan
Alternate Spellings	John W. Festeband, J. Festerbaur, Festervan, Festervand, John Fosterbeen, Festabund
Birth Year	Around 1798 (discrepancies suggest possibly 1818)
Birthplace	Holland
Residences	*1840: Madison, Mississippi *1841: Township, Madison County, Mississippi *1850: Township 19 Ward 4, Claiborne, Louisiana *1860: Wiseville, Claiborne, Louisiana
Death Date	Probably after April 2, 1860
Marriage	Nancy Wills (30 Aug 1836, Madison County, Mississippi)
Children	Andrew Jackson Festevan, Benjamin Franklin Festevan, Lucy J. Festevan, Marcella A. Festevan, Martha Ann Festervan, David Simmons Festevan
Naturalization	September 18, 1856 in Claiborne Parish, Louisiana
Testifying Persons	Henry Dyer, Joseph D. Long (neighbor in 1850 census)
Land Record	April 2, 1860, in Webster, Land District: Natchitoches, Louisiana
Citizenship Oath Details	Claimed to be a native subject of King William IV of Holland

Piecing together John's genealogical puzzle

As we delve into the intricate history of John's life, it becomes evident from our genealogical chart that there are significant gaps. Two primary pieces of the puzzle remain elusive: the circumstances of John's birth and the identities of his parents. Despite our extensive research, records that could shed light on these mysteries are yet to be discovered. This is where modern science steps in - we're turning to DNA testing to help fill these gaps.

 

Our collaborative team of genealogy researchers is keen on employing Y-DNA testing, which can trace the direct male lineage. Specifically, we're seeking a male Festevan, who descends directly from one of John W. Festevan's sons, to participate in this test.

 

At the moment, Family Tree DNA is offering their testing services at a discounted rate. If you, or someone in your family, fit the criteria and are interested in participating, we would love to hear from you. Your contribution could be instrumental in unlocking the secrets of John's ancestral lineage.

Stay tuned as I continue to unravel the mysteries surrounding the FESTEVAN lineage!

- Revis